The horizon is not so far as we can see, but as far as we can imagine

2024 Election Day Open Thread

Use to discuss the election and its aftermath.

Previous

If Kamala Wins It’ll Be the Supreme Court Who Won It For Her

Next

Trump Wins

27 Comments

  1. Revelo

    Just voted for Kamala Harris. USA will continue on its current bad trajectory with her as President, but at least she is a known bad quantity, whereas Trump is a dangerous loose cannon. My evil self wanted to vote Trump in hopes of seeing another insurrection and also send a big f*ck you to the Democrats, but my rational self reflected that I’ll have to live with whatever disaster Trump creates, so best do what I can to kick the USA can of reckoning down the road a few years.

  2. Predictions:
    Trump wins the presidency winning the 2020 Biden states of Arizona, Georgia, and Pennsylvania.
    Senate goes 51 R with Montana, and W Virginia being pick ups. Possible Independent upset in Nebraska and/or the Ohio senate seat going R.
    House goes 221-214 in favor of the Democratic Party.

  3. Predictions:
    Trump wins the presidency winning the 2020 Biden states of Arizona, Georgia, and Pennsylvania.
    Senate goes 51 R with Montana, and W Virginia being pick ups. Possible Independent upset in Nebraska and/or the Ohio senate seat going R.
    House goes 221-214 in favor of the Democratic Party.

  4. Same.

    If Kamala wins it will be nice to show my daughter that in America women can grow up to be mediocre presidents too.

  5. TimmyB

    I voted for Stein. I believe Trump will win and it won’t be close. Then he’ll start a war against Iran that we will lose. Sad times ahead.

  6. Purple Library Guy

    Guess it’s going to be an exciting Guy Fawkes day today.
    “Remember, remember
    the 5th of November
    Gunpowder, treason and plot!”

  7. mago

    Wake me up when it’s over so I can go back to sleep.

  8. bruce wilder

    I cannot grasp the calculus Revelo reports. Running off a cliff versus running into a ditch? Somewhat abstract metaphors for chaos and dysfunction either way.

  9. different clue

    Here is a little article about Trump’s first lawsuit of the election. It is titled . . . ” Trump Files First Election Lawsuit in Chilling Sign of What’s to Come “. Here is the link.
    https://thenewsglobe.net/?p=7820

    I would expect the Trump team and the Republican Party to file tens or maybe hundreds of such suits all over the country. It isn’t over until it is over. And maybe not even then.

  10. Mark Level

    I am watching the Due Dissidence podcast, & @ this point, they have 99 blue points for Pres, v. 188 for Trump. IF I am wrong to assume that Trump has a substantial lead (with mostly Libertarian/ Right Western states left), I apologize in advance.

    If the Dems aren’t rewarded for genocide, I’ll be happy.

    Let it be.

  11. Arthur

    As write this (8:49 PM CST) there have been no surprises. I voted for Harris and hope she wins, not because she will make a great president but because Trump is insane. The choice really does come down to slow motion decline or slam into the brick wall at 100mph without a seatbelt. That’s it. Sorry but anyone who thinks otherwise is delusional. Decline and fall are baked into the cake. That said I really won’t be surprised if Trump wins. I have no respect for most of my fellow citizens so why would I be surprised. That 70 million or so think he’s what the country needs tells the tale. It points to a complete failure of education, the arts, journalism, science and whatever else we believe will lift humanity. So, if Harris does win how could the country hope to go forward when facing that reality.

  12. Revelo

    @Bruce Wilder: I rushed my comment as I exited the voting station, so it is indeed confused. Trump victory would not lead to insurrection. On the contrary, it’s a Trump loss that might lead to insurrection. On the other hand, Trump victory might lead to something worse than insurrection. It’s the radical unpredictability of Trump that frightens me. Ukraine is a fine example of what can happen with radicals in charge of a country. Ukraine was slowly sliding into the ditch for decades prior to radicals taking control. Then it suddenly drove off a cliff. I don’t want that in the USA.

    Harris, if she wins, will be stymied by the Republican Senate. So I voted for gridlock, a predictable 4 years of continued slow sliding of the USA into the ditch, versus 4 years with increasingly mentally unstable Trump at the helm, possibly driving us off the cliff.

  13. anon

    I stand by what I said last week: https://www.ianwelsh.net/seven-days-till-the-us-federal-election/#comment-155197

    Trump will win. It has been obvious for a few weeks now. I did not believe that Harris was gaining momentum in the last several days like some pills indicated. Trump is wildly popular. Harris and Biden are wildly unpopular. The elites on the coasts reporting the news are so out of touch and clueless.

  14. Chinese Observer

    I don’t get it, for all of left’s lament about lack of consciousness in populace, you vote for establishment that bared its teeth for total domination of social life, that will guarantee a (possibly global) regress to neo-feudalism in 50 years time?
    Yeah no “CEO” of America will be against interest of the Board, even FDR can’t claim to be against the Board, for all that the left can possibly want, even nudging people to be a little more conscious is too great a task?

    The way i see it, if america can’t uphold standard of liberty, whatever class interest it actually serve, the chilling effect will make everything gray, there will only be a race to be least bad, while everyone spiral down, coincident with technology development in automation and ai, it will make everyone regress to feudalism, because the top won’t be needing the mass anymore, they will have their cottages and castles, without a technology leader to ensure in this transition the technology is not selectively developed to make the power gap between top and mass thrown into inbalance, this is the only outcome.

  15. Arthur

    Is the game over? Well, starting to look like it. Not much more to say than I said above except this: look outside right now in the sky and one see Jupiter. There might be life on one or more of its moons. It doesn’t care about Trump or Harris or anything down here. My point? Nature will have the final say. That’s something to hang on because our time is up.

  16. KT Chong

    Seems like MAGA is gonna take the White House, and the Senate, and the House, and of course the Supreme Court.

    The Supreme Court decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, which pushed women towards Democrats. That has been widely known and reported. That is to be expected.

    What is unexpected because it has been ignored and unreported: MEN.

    Men have been abandoning Democrats in similar margins. Whatever female votes that have been gained by Democrats have been effectively neutralized and even overcome by the male votes gained by Republicans.

    And in swing states, the gender gaps were enough to doom Democrats.

    Blacks and Latinos are not moving away from Democrats. It is Black MEN and Latino MEN who are.

    Now we are going to talk about why men are turning to Republicans.

  17. KT Chong

    Seems like we are in a new era of gender politics. Democrats, liberals and progressive have themselves to blame. They are the ones who got us into all these gender identities, and start to come up with new gender identities to divide and subdivide people.

    When you start to divide people along gender lines, then expect genders to replace races and become the new battlegrounds in politics. Democrats have always pandered to women and queer votes while demonizing men as toxic, so of course men would go to the other side.

  18. @TimmyB

    Based on what Iran has been saying I fear the war will start before Trump takes office. They are threatening a heavy strike, no more demonstrations, and are also threatening US bases in the ME.
    If their capabilities are what people like MIT’s Ted Postol and former UK ambassador Alistair Crooke are saying then they can basically flatten Isreal in one go.
    Which will invite either a nuclear response from Israel or a massive US intervention (which will be an epic disaster for the US).
    If US fleets or bases get obviously undeniably hammered, I greatly fear Biden will go nuclear.

  19. Soredemos

    Seems pretty safe to go to bed now roughly predicting the final result. Maybe things will change dramatically in seven or eight hours, but as of right now it looks like a fucking blowout. Trump looks set to take many, maybe even almost all, of the swing states. He’ll blow right past 270 votes, perhaps by a lot just to rub it in, and he’ll crush the popular vote by around five million.

    You can’t beat something with nothing. Reminder than Bernie would have won, in both 2016 and 2020. The Dems sabotaged him to make a dementia patient their candidate, then replaced him undemocratically with a uniquely empty pant suit who has now been utterly humiliated, and whom we will hopefully never hear of again. Richly deserved.

    Republicans don’t deserve to win. But Democrats absolutely deserve to lose.

  20. KT Chong

    So it turned out that Kamala’s problem with men was much bigger and deeper than Trump’s problem with women. Democrats have made gains with women after the Supreme Court had overturned Roe v. Wade. However, those gains have been completely neutralized and overcome by the hemorrhage of men from Democrats.

    Democrats should have dealt with their men problem a decade ago. Hillary lost the 2016 election also because of men. The warning signs were already loud and clear back then, but Dems chose to ignore the festering trouble because they have been (occasionally) made up with their (growing) male gender gale with women.

    Over the eight years, Democrats continued to gradually lose more and more men, and the loss has been accelerating in the past five years. At some point, they simply cannot make up this continuous hemorrhage of male votes with the gains they have made with women.

    By the time Kamala realized the problem, (like, LAST WEEK,) it was already too late. And then her campaign started to target men with ads and messages… only to tell men why they should care about abortion and women issues. None of her ads (not the one I’ve seen) mentioned any issues that were important or pertinent to men. That was certainly NOT helping, (certainly not after a decade of calling men toxic, deplorable and incel.) I think this anti-men is a culture thing and deep-seeded within the Dem Party, and it could be very difficult for Dems to adjust and overcome.

  21. KT Chong

    • The Man Problem: “Why Are Men Moving Right?” by Shoe0nHead:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tSw04BwQy4M

    Shoe0nHead’s videos are usually very funny, but this one is not. She is actually a good source for older people to learn about and understand young people.

    • The Wall Street Journal: Why So Many Young Men Are Turning Republican Now:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TP7V-r4A1rU

    ↑ Numbers and stats

    Scott Galloway is a NYU professor.

    • Scott Galloway: The REAL Reason MEN Are VOTING for TRUMP…
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jzLmznS91kM

    • Scott Galloway: 2024 election is a ‘battle over young men’
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=htm6ngi9leo

    • Scott Galloway on CNN: Young men feel abandoned by the Democratic party:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_XapCqE1w6k

    • CBC News: Why Donald Trump’s message is resonating with young men :
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XrZv-os03Hc

    • NBC News: More young men are showing support for Donald Trump:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RDW7o7Df1UU

    • NBC News: Trump’s team courts support from young men as gender gap in race widens:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-uBVB114SGs

    • Journalist on why Trump’s lead in polls with young men is ‘probably unrecoverable for Democrats’”:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BwMSbDAjZ8g

    • The ‘Bro’ Vote: Why more young men are increasingly supportive of Trump (ITV News):
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEsPjinFWPI&t=195s

    As a young man revealed at 3:15.

    • Chuck Todd: A Trump victory means ‘he got younger men to show up’ for the election (CNN)
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=daGGosUlF3M

  22. different clue

    Hillary lost her election because of men? Really? I thought she lost it because of NAFTA, WTO, MFN for China, etc. I still think I voted for Trump in 2016 because I wanted revenge for NAFTA, WTO, MFN, etc. Also I wanted revenge for the Democrats not letting me have the Sanders I wanted. They wouldn’t let me have my Sanders so I wouldn’t let them have their Clinton. Plus I wanted to spare myself the further Free Trade Conspiracies which Hillary was going to advance.

    Oh well . . . as Hirohito once said — ” The Presidential situation has developed in a way not necessarily to our advantage.”

  23. bruce wilder

    It’s the radical unpredictability of Trump that frightens me. Ukraine is a fine example of what can happen with radicals in charge of a country. Ukraine was slowly sliding into the ditch for decades prior to radicals taking control. Then it suddenly drove off a cliff. I don’t want that in the USA.

    Thank you, Revelo, for the explanation. Appreciated.

    Here’s the thing: Ukraine, with the Soviet Union, drove off the cliff circa 1990. The US institutionalized foreign policy establishment, in deep symbiosis with the military-industrial complex whose interest is perpetual war, pursued a policy of encouraging Russophobia, the better to motivate integration with the EU and NATO. The hostility to Russia was palpable in policy substance and in the personal identities of key personalities, in the U.S. and in country. Centrifugal tendencies in Ukraine were exacerbated while the supportive financial aid available to, say, Poland, was denied to Russia (and Ukraine, but dressed up with scolding about “anti-corruption” while Americans like Hunter Biden and Tony Podesta wet their beaks brazenly).

    This is the “stable” “normal” you wilfully know nothing about and defend.

    Is Trump against it? It is not clear to me that he is in any consistent way. But, that in his mercurial, impulsive way, he might destabilize the insanity, is a danger to be feared and postponed. Certainly, the Deep State fears Trump — all those impeachments, the lawfare, the assassination attempts, the b.s. about “our democracy” and fascism from people implementing a censorious surveillance state — and fear Trump more than whoever has been running the country during reign of the corrupt, senile Biden.

    I viscerally dislike Trump. I am no conservative or right-winger. But, I do not understand the complacent, morally bankrupt willful ignorance of the Democratic electorate and its Media Wurlitzer.

    Ymmv

  24. Curt Kastens

    I am going to attempt to do a summary of how humans got to where they are now from the very very very very begining. These are the miles markets on the yellow brick road.
    800,000 years ago humans tamed fire. This was the first step on the path to both civilization and unavoidable extinction because human civilization is inherently completely unsustainable for many reasons. All of the steps that follow this first step are inevitable consequences of this first “advancement”.
    250,000 years ago language begins to develope.
    200,000 years ago there are languages. This gave humans super powers. Language is a force multiplier. Knowledge could not only be passed on it could develope much faster.
    70,000 years ago humans develope the bow and arrow. Another super power is added to their capabilities.
    15,000 years ago. Dogs are domesticated. Now humans can hear and smell 10 times better in a manner of speaking. And they get a visual second perspective in the bush. One that can see underneath vegitation that blocks the view of humans. While humans can see over vegitation that blocks the view of dogs. With this step human over population becomes inevitable, along with environmental degredation. Humans will be far to short sighted to see where they are now headed. With fire, and bow and arrows and dogs the natural world has become totally unbalanced. The fall really begins picking up speed at this time. Humans just had their fall broken all the way delaying their inevitiable death several times.
    10,000 years ago agriculture begins to replace hunter gathering as the main way of life for human peoples. Over population and environmental degredation did not cause this transition but it eventually would have caused it if the transition did not happen sooner. With the developement of agriculture the carrying capacity of the planet increased. On the other hand an agricultural based life style made slavery possible for the first time.
    8,000 years ago the first animals, sheep, are domesticated.
    7,500 years ago the stone age ends with the manufacturing of copper tools.
    7,500 years ago the first city in the world reaches a population of 10,000 people.
    6,000 years ago the wheel was invented
    5,000 years ago for better and worse the first empires arise
    Humans were now on a plateu that would last for 4,400 years.
    Setting the stage for what was to come;
    1400 years ago Science started flourishing in the Islamic world
    700 years ago science began flourishing in Europe
    600 years ago the developement of fire arms began
    These last two events did not determine what would happen next, They determined who would do what to who in the big picture. I mean that the victory of English over the French in the 1700s was not predetermined but that European colonial expansion was. But even that is only a small detail for the planet. Though it is of course a major detail for those who died on slave ships going to Brazil or the United States. Yet in another deminsion of the universe the shoe might be on the other foot.
    300 years ago humans began transitioning from wood for energy to coal.
    Although this step might not have been directly caused by a lack of wood for cooking and smelting and building such a shortage of wood would have eventually occured. This was the final nail in humanity’s coffin. Now we only have to lie down in it and accept our comming fate. We humans did not know back then that coal and latter oil and natural gas would cause the planet to warm when they were burned. But by the middle of the 19th century some people had discovered that. But even if we humans had collectively know what the consequences of this change would be I highly doubt that we would have done anything differently. This choice would have been between suffering rapidly declining standards of living very soon or taking a chance on a new offer that would allow a massive improvement in standards of living for an indefinate period in to the future. The choice is basically live well and die or live at the living standard of a chimpanzee on the savanah for all time. If you ask me that is an obvious choice.
    Fossil fuels allowed for a massive population overshoot. They made us look like an intellegent species rather than the naked apes that we are. Very importantly fossil fuels greatly reinforced a foolish optomistic outlook in vast numbers of humans, specifically a foolish belief that tecnnology can solve all of our problems and deliver us to paradise.
    60 years ago more or less, some intellectualls began rasing an alarm about human society being unsustainable. But for the most part they were ignored. And i guess it was a great thing that they were ignored. Because their warnings came 800,000 years to late. To have even tried to have transitioned to a more sustainable society would have required that someone like Joseph Stalin, but only with a sense of humor, to be a world dictator. If huge sacrifices were not made they would have not have had nearly enough impact to make any worth while delay in the inevitable collapse of industrial civilization.
    55 years ago most people were oblivious as to what was instore for humanity in the comming century. But in at least one corner of the world the people were aware of what was comming. That corner of the world was a few rooms deep in the heart of the pentagon. That knowledge gave added impitus for creating their plans for war to achieve global domination. So that while others died they could survive.
    But those ploting to survive were so naive it is astonishing. But we can thank our lucky stars that they were in charge. Because by plotting to dominate the world they accidently give the impression that there will be something left over to dominate. And on top of that it gives the rest of a motive to live as long as possible, the motive to torture and murder them for their massive betrayel of public trust.
    In the mean time every person who understands where we are and how we got here is faced each day with a terrible decision. To pretend that we can get our solve our sustainability problems and keep hope alive, which murders the truth. Or to explain why we are way way way past the point of no return which defends truth but murders hope.

  25. Curt Kastens

    OOps I forgot to put the developement of writing on my mile marker list. May Dorthy forgive me. I also wanted to put in when the Book the Wizard of Oz was written and when the movie came out.

  26. Curt Kastens

    German elections on Feb. 23rd 2025. I wonder if the world’s temprature on that day will be 2.23° above the preindustrial average.

  27. Curt Kastens

    I think that I should have included the development of the printing press in my mile markers of how humanity got to this point. Not writing though. Before the printing press the literate population was so small that writing does not deserve a hi lite. But the printing press not only resulted in the masses learning to read it resulted in the creation of still another unsustainable industry.
    But an industry that incapsulates the same question as fossil fuels but on a smaller scale. Is a short history that includes great works of art like The Eithiopian and Frankenstein better than a long history with fewer great works of art spread out over a much longer time span or worse.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén