If the Irish vote in a referendum for austerity, then they deserve what they get. Current polls are showing Greeks will probably vote for pro-austerity parties as well, if so, again, my sympathy will be out. Democracy is about getting what you vote for, if countries vote for austerity, then they deserve it.
Oaktown Girl
Does anybody here know the situation regarding ease and access to voting for the poor and working class in Greece? I’m just wondering if that factors in at all.
Jack Crow
This sentiment suggests that voters have a rational choice. They do not. Nor does it cover the millions of people who cannot or do not vote.
Ian Welsh
Voters have a clear choice in both these cases. Democracy is about choices and voters have to accept the responsibility.
People who do not vote when there are actually clear choices deserve the opprobrium heaped on them.
People must either admit they have no power, in which case there should be a revolution, or must accept responsibility for the forseeable consquences of their votes.
Again, in both cases, the vote is clear and fair. People know what they’re voting for.
Austerity does not work, it has never worked. It does not take a lot of research to find this out.
Roman Berry
Doesn’t the pro-austerity campaign in both Ireland and Greece amount to a campaign of mobster…er…bankster threats saying “Vote this way or else!”?
Alcuin
And watch the American voters vote for Romney in spades. And get austerity in spades. If Americans had any convictions (they do not – their minds have been rotted by television), they’d vote for anyone except Robama or Obomney, but they won’t. We’re so f**ked.
Declan
Agreed Ian.
We (or at least I) have a tendency to think of Europe and Canada as being ‘ahead’ of the U.S. in the sense of not being quite as screwed up. But I wonder sometimes if Europe and Canada are just behind the U.S. and our George Bushes and Barack Obama’s are still to come (Harper being PM suggests Canada isn’t too far behind, but the pro-plutocracy vote is still only in the 30-40% range here, so we may have a ways to go).
Notorious P.A.T.
“they deserve what they get”
I have no problem with people getting what they deserve. I do have a problem with me getting what they deserve.
Notorious P.A.T.
“If Americans had any convictions, they’d vote for anyone except Robama or Obomney, but they won’t”
No doubt. Maybe America deserves to fail. I tell people “vote for a third party. how about Jill Stein?” But no, they can’t do that–that would be wasting their vote. So they cast their vote for someone who they know will enact policies they don’t agree with; you know, putting their vote to good use, not wasting it.
Hardly anyone cares that the president thinks he can kill anyone he wants. If he can get away with that, he can get away with anything.
” they do not – their minds have been rotted by television”
There were nations of lazy, callous people long before television.
Alcuin
@ Notorious P.A.T.: – Yeah, I’ve got a problem with getting what they deserve too.
As to your other point, yes, true. But television has homogenized and spread the callousness. Before, there was at least the possibility of a few people pointing out that the local Scrooge was evil. Now, with Koch-dollars, far more people can be infected. At one point in our history, shame and shunning worked – now, with the mass-media, idiots of all stripes are celebrated. How likely is it that a modern day Joseph N. Welch would take down a modern-day Joseph McCarthy with the immortal words, “Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?” Who has the courage to call out Obama on his drone selection list in the mass media? Who has the courage to take down the likes of Gingrich, Santorum, Limbaugh, O’Reilly, Bachman, Coulter, and others of their ilk, to lasting effect? There are vastly too many sub-human creatures who are encouraged by the violence and cruelty of television to even think about their actions. And the churches encourage such behavior!!
xraymike79
You would think the unwashed masses would not vote for a Wall Street vulture capitalist, but we may well be in a cycle of one term presidents as a sign that the citizenry are frustrated with the reality of never returning to the bygone days of cheap energy, housing bubbles, and credit cards , all the while fantasizing that he and his children still had a chance to become part of the 1%. But alas, the dream will soon become a nightmare for many.
Morocco Bama
I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again. We are well past the point of electing our way out of the catastrophe that’s unfolding in slow motion.
Notorious P.A.T.
“You would think the unwashed masses would not vote for a Wall Street vulture capitalist”
And you would think they would not vote for someone with a secret “kill list” that includes American citizens.
someofparts
You know, somebody more imaginative than I am could launch an entire new series of sci-fi tales based on a quasi-imaginary future where Canada is the only fit place to live in the Western hemisphere. The Hudson Bay area becomes temperate, and the southeastern U.S. gets a climate as hellish as it’s culture.
someofparts
Oh, almost forgot. While we deplore the folly of the Greeks and the Irish, don’t forget Wisconsin. If Walker wins the recall, Wisconsin voters will deserve the same dismissal.
Bernard
thinking? when and who does that nowadays. PR marketing has done the so-called “thinking” most Americans accept without question.
some things never change. Fear is the only rule today, at least in America. Fear of the “other”, fear of taxes, fear of society, Fear all around, to keep the “sheep” in line, to slaughtering house.
Such a successful con job on Americans, why bother to think at all. Empires are obviously built this way, and fall that way, as well.
how can anyone have sympathy for people, like the Irish or Greeks or Americans, who vote for Austerity and Neo Con concepts. willful ignorance has accomplished so much, for the 1%.
someofparts
“I have no problem with people getting what they deserve. I do have a problem with me getting what they deserve.”
May I use this line elsewhere? I’m thinking t-shirt.
Growth Factor
Really, there is a point that is alluded to up-thread that I would like to emphasize. I cannot speak to Europe, or even Canada, but here in the Southern US where I live, pro-1% propaganda is so thick and so deep that most people have literally no idea what lies beyond the curtain. Even the European liberals around here (my girlfriend among others) are still smitten with Obama. When I start listing all of the Civil Liberty rollbacks, bombings, assassinations, the bank ass-kissing, they become silent. They are simply unaware of how bad things have become.
Americans are overwhelmed at home and at work. They get what little news they digest from sources on TV and the Radio owned and operated by the 1%. Sources that are going to blind them to their own self interest while serving the interests of the rich and powerful.
Pity, not scorn, is how I feel about my fellow Americans. The overwhelming majority are unaware that their news sources are biased and compromised, and do not have ready access to sources of information that would give them a clear picture of their own self interest. Indeed, part of the propaganda conditioning we receive inoculates us against trusting alternative information sources.
I would be surprised if this dynamic is not also playing out in Greece and in other European countries as well.
Notorious P.A.T.
If you’re looking for a Sci Fi story about the future, try “World Made By Hand” by James Kunstler.
http://worldmadebyhand.com/
xraymike79
@ Bernard,
Well said!
Notorious P.A.T.
Go ahead, someofparts . If you get rich off of it, I want a share 😉
someofparts
Growth Factor, I’m in the South too. Born and raised as it happens.
All the middle class people I know have more money, free time and access to online news sources than I do, but they could care less about using it. If their Facebook pages are to be believed, they care about themselves, their vacations, their music and their sports teams pretty much exclusively.
I can’t avoid concluding that they are petty, lazy and smug. I hardly think that makes them monsters, but it does appear to make them unfit to hold onto the wealth their hard-working ancestors bequeathed to them. They have not cared one whit while their owners made beggars of the working class, and I’m afraid my working class ears will be deaf to their whines when the devil comes for them.
someofparts
“Go ahead, someofparts . If you get rich off of it, I want a share”
Absolutely.
The real money will start to pour in when I put in on little costumes people can buy for their dogs.
Bill H
“When I start listing all of the Civil Liberty rollbacks, bombings, assassinations, the bank ass-kissing, they become silent.”
Yes, I can relate. I keep trolling liberal blogs, simply because I am actually a liberal, and start talking about the same things and I get, “but, health care.” That’s not hard to destroy, and then I get silence. Except when they call me bad names.
Notorious P.A.T.
and I get, “but, health care.”
Yes, the only way we could have gotten this health care plan was to vote for Obama.
Notorious P.A.T.
I heartily sympathize, though. I go to liberal blogs, too, to see if anyone is upset that the president believes he can have an American killed without trial or charges. Almost no one is. At least I can never let them forget it.
Petro
TBogg needs to be slapped around a bit again. And y’all seem like the folk to do it:
Nobama Slam Poetry Hatefest & Disappointment Caucus Is In The House
I don’t have the energy.
StewartM
MB:
Most of my adult life it feels I’ve been watching a train wreck unfold before me. There were a number of times it could have been averted, and maybe 2008 was the last time.
-StewartM
Celsius 233
Growth Factor
June 1, 2012
Pity, not scorn, is how I feel about my fellow Americans. The overwhelming majority are unaware that their news sources are biased and compromised, and do not have ready access to sources of information that would give them a clear picture of their own self interest. Indeed, part of the propaganda conditioning we receive inoculates us against trusting alternative information sources.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I find that beyond belief. Willful ignorance and denial would seem to be the reality in this day and age.
Bernard
i might have pity on the unaware, and hurt, but these “willfully ignorant” middle class zombies are doing damage to those who want no part of the hatred and fear used as a “lever” to suck all our “civilized” American values down the drain. the wanton destruction of our Society, schools, roads, public lands, streams, air we all breathe is “Our” problem. All of us live together.
however far apart we seem to be we are stil interdependent upon the whole of society working. the Middle Class has been so afraid of becoming poor, they totally ignore any sign of poverty or how poverty is increasing all across America.
the FEAR of being poor is all the Elites need to sow the seeds of “differences”/better than. the Middle Class must always be “scared into” remembering which side of the class lines they hope to be. and that is always one up on and better than those poor “losers.” Women, Hippies, Immigrants, Gays, Muslims, the list is long and used quite smartly to keep the White Working Class afraid of becoming one of “them.”
the Southern Plantation was a foretaste and the model of how to set one class of society against each other so the Elites can reap all the MONEY, while the “Us vs. Them” does its’ insidious leaching of community/societal values.
Rednecks have always been raised to fear being a Poor Black and nowadays that includes Mexicans and Muslims. gosh, such an endless supply of “Them” to scare the Whites into shooting themselves in the foot.
Success is not to be messed with, lest anyone dare “educate” the dumb Whites who support the Elites. Such a good thing is a finely tuned instrument requiring constant “attention/PR marketing/Scaring Whites.” At least down here in the South.
that’s been the winning ticket and has been since Cotton was king.
The American Dream as told by John Wayne, George Wallace and the mighty of all mighty Capitalistic Communists, St. Ronnie.
not the American Dream/Reality as told by George Carlin.
the willfully ignorant are not worthy of pity, only scorn.
Celsius 233
Bernard PERMALINK
June 1, 2012
…the willfully ignorant are not worthy of pity, only scorn.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Indeed. It’s all there for those who care.
But the Botinization of the American public is nearly complete…
Declan
“You know, somebody more imaginative than I am could launch an entire new series of sci-fi tales based on a quasi-imaginary future where Canada is the only fit place to live in the Western hemisphere. ”
It was written in 1955 – ‘The Chrysalids’ by John Wyndham – we had to read it in school. New Zealand was also spared.
For an intermediate stage, try, ‘The Handmaid’s Tale’ by Margaret Atwood.
Morocco Bama
Bernard, there is much truth in what you say, but the blame “Whitey” card is becoming increasingly transparent and irrelevant. What you describe is the Western way of life, and regardless of “race,” if you play the game well, you get rewarded. Yes, you lose your soul, but there’s no lack of volunteers for that, last time I looked, and those endless volunteers who are willing and ready to hand over their metaphorical souls come from all walks of life….meaning they’re not just “Whitey.” The fact of the matter is, this System pits one against the other. We all are required to pay to live, and people will, and do, stab each other in the back in that process. It’s not a System predicated upon collaboration, cooperation and mutual respect. It’s exactly the opposite….and that’s why there were death camps and crematoriums in Germany, and there could easily be the same here when, and if, the Zeitgeist presents itself. When the message is, “it’s you or the other guy, and that other guy doesn’t want you to have it” then it doesn’t take too much of a prod for an indoctrinated dolt to accept annihilation and genocide when they start to feel poignantly threatened.
Petro
@Morocco Bama – That is as excellent an indictment of Capitalism as I’ve read anywhere.
guest
How does Bernard explain the way Africans and Latin Americans structure their societies and treat their own so callously and brutally? Blaming whites for human nature is just as bad as your typical white republican who somehow sees his/her standard(i.e. worthless) education as setting them and the white race somehow above the foolishness of things like Keynesian economics, evil socialism or anything associated with blacks.
And it looks like the Irish have voted for continued austerity. A so-called well educated advanced country that does this to itself does not bode well for a country largely run by people with the depth of Bachman or Ron Paul or Boner (or Obama for that matter. Whatever his ivy league credentials, I have never seen or heard anything from him that did not reek of stale, unoriginal, middle of the road, middlebrow conventional wisdom).
Notorious P.A.T.
Tbogg is–how do I put this diplomatically?–kind of an asshole, huh?
“If you can’t prove that Romney would be better than Obama, than vote for Obama!” No thanks.
Alcuin
@MB: – you might be interested in reading up on something called “social justification theory”. I haven’t read much about it, but what I have read illustrates exactly how hierarchies are legitimized and reproduced. Very interesting. The most prominent writer about the theory is John T. Jost. He wrote a book review of The Fair Society for The American Scientist that I thought was fascinating.
Treese
The fact of the matter is, this System pits one against the other
And where did this system come from? Another planet? And we are the victims?
If there were no white men the enemy would be fabricated using another standard. If you never contemplate the source of competition it will shape shift eternally. Blaming the system is as useless as blaming the other. That’s called giving away power.
I agree that hierarchies are reproduced. But why? Perhaps there is a valid reason. As long as you consider the fact that people might not be geared toward divine goodness overall, then there is hope. Or something. People get along when they have to. Equality comes and goes. Value judgements seem to dominate our every waking moment. Geography determines quite a bit. The arguments about justice and equality get tedious and hackneyed and are used to fix fractured egos and personalities with questionable compassion. Convincing one’s self and fooling others, the age old game.
The hierarchy teaches us to share. The societies based on reciprocity are fascinating. Status is earned through giving and shared resources offers protection against depletion. “I’ll take two goats and see you five chickens. And a basket of yams.”
Somehow the whole thing works out. What system is really in charge? There’s actually a fair amount of reciprocity in our culture. Social engineering of a fair society is suspect and blaming whites is ludicrous. Squirrels are awful too. Horrid. Powerful. They ruin my summers.
Morocco Bama
And where did this system come from? Another planet? And we are the victims?
You are inferring something I did not imply. I’m not blaming the System. I’m merely stating it’s at the center of it all, and yes, each and everyone of us helps to perpetuate it on a daily basis….some voluntarily and with much gusto and zeal, and other sever so reluctantly and with antipathy. Nonetheless, the System rules the day, and if you want to live, you must feed it to some degree.
For 8 billion people to collectively live together on this planet with ever diminishing resources, they will have to do so by some form of a System, whether it be thoughtfully planned and implemented, or it’s unwittingly and unconsciously conjured. The numbers are too great and the stakes too high to return to the days of small communities of Dunbar’s 150, or less, unless there is a calamity of some sort, at which point it’s quite possible such small, scattered communities may rule the day.
The point being, one way or another, being the social animals we are, we’re going to interact according to a codified and/or uncodified set of social rules and customs. That arrangement can be organic and unconscious, or it can be quite formal and deliberate. Despite the fact that the current iteration of it allows for reciprocation in no way precludes the fact that in general, “this System pits one against the other.” It’s a System of accumulation and concentration, where the value of everything, imputed, or otherwise, is passed from the bottom of the pyramid to the blessed at the top…..and for lack of a better word, it can be called tribute, and if you want to live any kind of quality of life, you must pay it to this Beast.
It’s interesting you mentioned “from another planet” in jest. I’ve been chewing on this idea for quite some time now. I’m an Agnostic, but this concept came from the Gnostics, and it helps explain a great deal. There does seem to be something more at play here, and it help explain why it is so difficult to slay this Beast of a system. It’s called an Egregore, and I believe we have conjured one of massive proportions…..and it’s a suicidal maniac.
http://www.chaosmatrix.org/library/chaos/texts/gegregor.html
Treese
I think the system pits one against the other at times and bonds one with the other sometimes, according to the requests of the moment. Maybe it’s all right as is. The idea that humans are poised to alter it drastically is egocentric. It’s an overestimation of power.
I’m a metaphysician who lives in multi dimensions. I’ve thought that maybe I should read it more literally, but that would mean getting tangled up in the daily agony. I’m a micro/macrocosm person. I think the universe is like gears, and that we are one mini system turning another keeping the whole thing humming. Black holes do actually hum in musical notes that are imperceptible to the human ear. The physicists have deciphered them. Systems begetting systems, dying and being born. The connection to cosmic orchestration is my source of freedom. It goes with my dictum that no one is in charge. Who and what exactly am I supposed to fear? We are specks in time.
An egregore has the characteristic of having an effectiveness greater than the mere sum of its individual members.
Yes. That’s the macrocosm. The sum creates another entity altogether. All relationships do this. I lean toward trusting this entity, so I try to cooperate with it, despite my petty complaints and pesky idealism. Like the financial downfall. I don’t feel victimized by it. It’s high time. And according to egregore theory, a memory of something successful might reappear. I think we have knowledge that we can access at will when needed. The inner and outer dimensions are busy. The wizards are tricky. Alignments occur then disintegrate as circumstance demands. We know more than we know.
I see experience as sequential and no part can be deleted or it would fuck up the rhythm. What we see as wrong is probably right. We’re just immersed and can’t perceive the weave. The same with the politicians, the corporations, the evil ones, and all of them. They are a necessary part of the weave. Mere specks.
What is an egregore? It is the psychic and astral entity of a group
That includes this one.
There does seem to be something more at play here
Yes there does. I will have to disagree with the idea that our egregore is maniacally suicidal. I doubt that. We’ll all get safely to our deaths one by one.
That arrangement can be organic and unconscious, or it can be quite formal and deliberate
Therein lies the puzzle.
Morocco Bama
Treese, those are some good, and valid, points, and what makes them so salient, is that what you say, and what I say, can both be true, concomitantly. Preclusion doesn’t have to be the order of the day…..just one of many orders on any old day.
That being said, I do believe that the collective of humanity, and indeed just one individual human, has incredible power to shape the world and universe. The world and universe are limited to our cognitive perception, and as such, our reality can be constructed in exponential ways. For whatever reason, we’ve collectively engaged this version, generally speaking. Sure, everyone’s reality differs within a range, but there is significant overlap from one individual to another, and that overlap forms the collective consensus reality. Considering that, the world and universe are literally what we make of it, and we are just beginning to rediscover that awesome power. Astronomy and Cosmology are transforming every year, or less now, it seems, and these transformations are not subtle….they’re literally reality shattering. Sure, they are lofty disciplines, but if that same trend affects the entire consensus reality in which we all live our daily lives, and I think we’re on the precipice of that, then the consensus reality will be rocked to its core. It could, if accepted properly and constructively, allow humankind to enter a dynamic new age of thought and consciousness….one heretofore considered impossible, and the reality/realities that ensue could be utter bliss in comparison to the predecessor reality/realities.
So much is possible, and yet so little is probable considering the current reality and capacity.
StewartM
Bernard:
I think you vastly underestimate the brainwashing they have received. Those that are in power now were in college in the 1970s, I saw them, and these were the ones targeted by the conservative and libertarian propagandists. Most people form their impressions of “how the world works” at some early age and don’t fundamentally question or revisit that worldview later. Education, for its part, often acts to *cement* that worldview against dissonant facts more than it allows for restructuring it.
So, to the well-propagandized, if what they are told would work isn’t working, the “answer” is to double-down on what’s not working even more so. If stupidity is defined as keep trying what has never worked in the past, call this “educated stupidity”.
-StewartM
someofparts
Posting this in case Ian hasn’t see it yet.
http://www.georgesoros.com/interviews-speeches/entry/remarks_at_the_festival_of_economics_trento_italy/
Treese
mb.
Yes. Concomitance.
Sure, everyone’s reality differs within a range, but there is significant overlap from one individual to another, and that overlap forms the collective consensus reality.
Consensus reality. That’s where I get lost. The daily chaos vaguely represents reality to me, yet I must overlap. I’ve been doing more of that lately, but I still wonder what I’m doing here, caught in this whirlwind of collective emotion, trying to tame it. It’s so true about the cosmological advances, and that keeps me interested, in keeping with your idea that consensus reality could catapult to that lofty level. Rocked to its core to arrive in a state of utter bliss? I have some doubts.
I do think we’ve come to realize that technology might not equate with progress the way we once thought it would, and that could lead to a major adjustment. Every solution is followed by another terrible problem, but if consciousness develops, we might comprehend that as the natural process. We seem to get out of every jam as a species, and I expect that to continue. Of course there are no guarantees. Fearing the worst seems to be useless. The worst comes and goes.
In the meantime, the agony of social decay, interpersonal evisceration on the political stage, economic panic, and overall battering horror when faced with life’s realities are not my idea of daily nourishment. But the crowd relishes it, and if I get a seat at the table, I will brace myself properly.
I’m reluctant to immerse myself in the concept of a new dynamic age, not with any measure of belief attached to it anyway. I expect the many realities to fade in and out as they always do, while I work with my techniques in shaping them to my liking, perhaps tapping into that power you identified.
Anyway, if the material world does a number to mankind, I know nothing about who is at fault and who deserves what. If sacrifices are required , it’s entirely possible that spiritual gains will be made instead, which could influence the consensus reality, although, as I said, bliss is likely to be just beyond the crowd’s permanent grasp. I’ll settle for simple pleasure.
Wealth is constantly in flux. It moves up, then downward, then sideways. If it truly gets too top heavy it will fall naturally. Taxation has an almost mystical quality we have yet to understand collectively. Monetary policy always lands in the 7th circle of hell. We don’t know to whom we owe what, and who is designated to care for whom. Where exactly is the hand that feeds us?